“Don’t worry. The internet is forever.” – Some Guy on the Street
Everyone has heard it. It’s half true, which is the most dangerous kind of true.
Digital evidence is less like masonry and more like milk. Every platform stamps its own expiration date on the carton, and almost nobody reads the label until the case starts to curdle. Here’s a quick tour of the dairy aisle. (Policies change, so treat these numbers as a starting point and verify them before you rely on them.)
Isn’t everything online stored somewhere forever?
My usual message is: it can be ephemeral but it can also last forever. It can be gone in seconds but can sometimes persist for decades.
A screenshot, a forwarded email, or a cloud backup nobody remembers turning on can persist. But the platform’s own copy, the one you can authenticate cleanly through a records custodian, often has a short and very specific shelf life.
Just because data still exists doesn’t mean you can get to it, and just because it’s been deleted doesn’t mean it’s gone.
What about plain old text messages?
Carriers mostly don’t keep what you said. They keep who you said it to and when – for a little while, at least. A Justice Department chart that surfaced in 2011 showed Verizon holding text content for three to five days and AT&T keeping none, while call and text records ran anywhere from one year to seven. That chart dates to 2010, which in retention-policy years is roughly Paleolithic. Check the carrier’s current law-enforcement or legal-compliance guidance.
The phone (or computer) itself is usually the better witness.
On an iPhone, deleted photos generally remain in Recently Deleted for 30 days, while deleted messages may be recoverable there for roughly 30 to 40 days. They can be (and in my experience, often are) deleted from Recently Deleted sooner than that, however. After that, recovery is another matter, especially on modern phones with encrypted flash storage. Don’t count on it lasting very long at all. Modern flash storage tidies up after itself far more diligently than the old spinning hard drives ever did.
Snapchat? I thought that stuff just disappears.
Mostly, it does. Snapchat generally deletes Snaps after everyone has viewed them, and unopened Snaps normally disappear from its servers after 31 days. Chats play by somewhat different rules, and users can save some content or change deletion settings. Whatever survives may be on someone’s device, in saved chat content, or in another copy.
WhatsApp and Signal are encrypted. So I guess we’re just out of luck?
Not out of luck, just knocking on the wrong door. WhatsApp doesn’t keep delivered messages, and undelivered ones are held in encrypted form for up to 30 days before deletion. Signal is even more spartan. When subpoenaed, it has repeatedly been able to produce only the date an account was created and the date it last connected. Two timestamps. That’s the whole buffet.
The conversations ordinarily live on the participants’ phones, where a forensic examination may recover them if the device and its security settings permit. WhatsApp conversations may also be present in cloud backups. Signal handles backups differently, including an optional encrypted backup service that even Signal cannot decrypt without the user’s recovery key.
What happens when someone deletes a Facebook or X account?
Facebook generally gives users 30 days to cancel an account deletion, but removing the underlying content can take considerably longer if you’re lucky (or unlucky, depending on your perspective in a case), and backup or legally retained copies may survive. X also allows a 30-day deactivation period before deleting an account. Neither deadline tells you precisely when every copy of its data disappears.
Workplace tools keep everything, right?
Depends on who’s paying. Since August 2024, free Slack workspaces delete messages and files older than a year on a rolling basis; paid plans keep everything by default unless someone sets a shorter policy. On free plans, users can ordinarily see only the most recent 90 days, even when older material hasn’t yet been deleted. In Microsoft 365, deleted work or school OneDrive and SharePoint files generally remain in recycle bins for up to 93 days, unless retention settings change that. Exchange Online ordinarily retains a message for 14 days after it is removed from Deleted Items, extendable to 30 by an administrator. Litigation holds and retention policies can preserve evidence much longer.
What about location history and doorbell cameras?
Google moved Maps Timeline from its servers onto users’ devices. Data that wasn’t migrated by the applicable deadline was subject to deletion, and the default auto-delete period for new Timeline users is three months. Users can change that setting or enable encrypted backups. So the old “just subpoena Google” reflex may come back empty.
Ring keeps cloud video only with a subscription, defaulting to 60 days in the US (30 for 4K devices), adjustable up to 180.
So, what’s a boy to do?
There’s no need to panic. Just move faster than the expiration dates.
Send preservation letters early. To opposing counsel, to your own client, and to any third party likely to hold the data.
Know the law enforcement tool, and its limits. Under the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2703(f), a government entity can ask a provider to preserve records for 90 days, renewable for another 90. Civil litigants generally can’t compel message content from providers under the SCA, which puts more weight on the parties’ own devices and accounts. Preservation protects records that still exist; obtaining them requires separate legal authority. How that all plays out in your jurisdiction is your department, not mine.
Image the devices. The phone in someone’s pocket often outlasts every server in this article.
Ask about backups. iCloud, Google Drive, the old laptop in the closet. Encryption locks the front door; but remember to check and see if there are spare copies somewhere, like under the mat.
The internet isn’t forever. It’s more like a refrigerator: things keep for a while, as long as somebody remembers they’re in there. Then it’s a science project, or with luck, a forensic one.
Have you ever encountered a short retention window that caught you by surprise? I’d love to hear about it.
Burgess Forensics: (866) 345-3345 | steve@burgessforensics.com
